ars-rebuttal-audit

---

disable-model-invocation: true name: ars-rebuttal-audit description: ARS academic-paper rebuttal-audit mode — QA an existing rebuttal draft against reviewer comments model: sonnet

First invoke the Skill tool with skill: "academic-research-skills:academic-paper". Pass the mode and the user's request described below as its arguments. Use the loaded skill and its supporting files before producing the result.

Trigger the academic-paper skill in rebuttal-audit mode. Requires BOTH the reviewer comments AND an existing rebuttal/response draft to evaluate. Produces an advisory QA report (per-comment coverage + gaps + risk flags). Does NOT generate a new response, and does NOT emit Schema 11 / Material Passport / verified status (standalone invocation runs outside the pipeline). Fidelity spectrum, low oversight.

If only reviewer comments are present (no draft yet), use revision-coach instead.

Mode reference: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/MODE_REGISTRY.md § academic-paper. Skill entry: ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/academic-paper/SKILL.md.

Resolve plugin resources from ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}, not from the paper project's working directory. If the skill or a required file cannot be loaded, report the loading failure and stop; do not substitute this command summary for the mode instructions.